A prenuptial agreement is only worth having if it works when you need it. And one of the strongest things you can do to make sure it does is simple: each of you takes your own legal advice, from your own solicitor.
It can feel unnecessary, especially if you and your partner get on well and agree on everything. But independent advice is not about distrust. It is about making sure both of you understand what you are signing, and that the agreement stands the best possible chance of being respected if the marriage ever ends.
The Short Answer
- In England and Wales, there is no law that says a prenup is invalid without independent legal advice.
- But courts look closely at whether each person freely entered into the agreement and understood its consequences. Independent legal advice is one of the clearest ways to show that.
- A prenup is not automatically binding in England and Wales. It carries real weight when it is fair, properly made and fully informed, following Radmacher v Granatino [2010] UKSC 42.
- One solicitor generally cannot advise both of you, because your interests may conflict.
What Does “Independent Legal Advice” Actually Mean?
It means that each partner meets privately with their own prenup solicitor, who acts only for them. That solicitor should:
- Explain the legal position on divorce, including what the court would be likely to do if there were no agreement.
- Explain what the prenup changes and what you would be giving up or protecting.
- Review the other person's financial disclosure and raise questions where something looks incomplete.
- Advise on whether the terms are fair and likely to stand up, including how the court treats needs and children.
- Make sure you are not under pressure, and that the decision is genuinely your own.
Many agreements end with a short statement, often called a certificate of independent legal advice, confirming that each person has received this advice. It is a helpful part of the paper trail, though it works best when the advice behind it was genuinely thorough.
Why Independent Advice Matters
It Helps Show You Understood What You Signed
Courts applying Radmacher want to see that each person entered the agreement with a full appreciation of its implications. If one person later says they did not understand what they gave up, a record of detailed legal advice makes that argument much harder.
It Reduces the Risk of a Later Challenge
When a prenup is challenged, the usual arguments are pressure, poor disclosure or unfairness. A prenup lawyer who has advised you independently, checked the disclosure and discussed fair terms is helping to close off each of those lines of attack before they arise.
It Protects the Weaker Negotiating Position
When one partner is wealthier, older, more experienced or more commercially confident, the other may feel unable to question the terms. Independent advice levels that playing field. It gives each person a professional who can say, “This is reasonable,” or, “You should ask for more.”
It Makes the Agreement Fairer
Because courts will not uphold a prenup that leaves someone without their reasonable needs, balanced agreements are far more likely to survive. A solicitor acting for you has a clear reason to flag one-sided terms early, which helps both of you.
Why One Solicitor Cannot Act for Both of You
It may seem cheaper and simpler to share a lawyer. But in a prenup, your interests are, by nature, different. One person is often trying to protect assets, while the other is trying to make sure they are properly provided for. A solicitor cannot give frank advice to both sides at once, and professional conduct rules on conflicts of interest generally prevent it.
If you share a solicitor, the court may see the agreement as less reliable, and either of you could later argue you were not properly advised. The same concern applies to using an online template with no advice at all.
What Happens If There Is No Independent Advice?
The absence of legal advice does not automatically make a prenup unenforceable. But it can weaken the agreement considerably, because the court has less evidence that each person understood the consequences. Combined with other issues, such as last-minute signing or weak disclosure, the risk grows.
If you have already signed a prenup without advice, or you are not sure how well it was prepared, it is worth speaking to a solicitor to review it. Where appropriate, you can often reaffirm or improve the agreement after marriage.
What Prenuptial Agreement Services Typically Include
When you instruct a solicitor, the service usually covers:
- An initial consultation to understand your assets, goals and concerns.
- Guidance on financial disclosure, including what to gather and share.
- Drafting or reviewing the agreement.
- Negotiation with the other person's solicitor to reach balanced terms.
- A final advice meeting before signing, to confirm you understand each clause.
- Support with timing, so the agreement is signed well ahead of the wedding.
- Later review, when major changes happen, such as children, a business sale or a move abroad.
Our guide on what financial information is needed for a prenup can help you prepare before your first meeting.
How to Choose the Right Prenup Solicitor
Not every solicitor offers the same level of experience in this area. When comparing options, consider:
- Regulation: Check that the firm is regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority, and that you can find them on the SRA register.
- Family law experience: Ask how often the team deals with prenuptial and postnuptial agreements.
- Clear communication: You should come away understanding the process, not confused by jargon.
- Transparent costs: Ask for a clear explanation of how fees work before you commit.
- Independence: Make sure the solicitor acts only for you, not for your partner.
- Approachability: This is a personal subject. You should feel comfortable asking difficult questions.
Common Concerns, Answered
“Won't it damage trust if I ask for a lawyer?” It rarely does. Most couples find that a clear, fair agreement, reached with proper advice on both sides, makes the conversation easier, not harder.
“My partner has said I don't need one.” Please treat that with care. Everyone has the right to independent advice, and a fair agreement should welcome it. If you feel pressured, our guide on what happens if one partner doesn't want a prenup may help.
“I'm not sure I want to sign.” That is completely your right. Read more about whether you can refuse to sign a prenuptial agreement.
The Law May Change, but the Advice Stays Important
In June 2026, the Ministry of Justice opened a consultation, A Fairer End to Relationships, which includes proposals for legally binding “qualifying nuptial agreements”. It closed on 14 August 2026, and at the time of writing it has not become law. If it does, safeguards such as independent advice and proper disclosure are widely expected to remain important. Taking advice now means your agreement is built on solid foundations whichever way the law develops.
Talk to Regent Law's Family Law Team
At Regent Law, we help individuals and couples across England understand their options and prepare clear, balanced prenuptial agreements. Our team is based in Blackburn, and we work with clients nationwide, always explaining each step in plain language.
We offer a free, no-obligation assessment, so you can ask questions and understand the process before deciding what to do.
Book a Consultation | Call 01204 201296 | WhatsApp 07555 161516
Sources and Further Reading
- Radmacher (formerly Granatino) v Granatino [2010] UKSC 42
- Law Commission, Matrimonial Property, Needs and Agreements (2014)
- Ministry of Justice, A Fairer End to Relationships (consultation, June 2026)
- Solicitors Regulation Authority, SRA Standards and Regulations (conflicts of interest)
Frequently Asked Questions
It is strongly recommended. Each person should have their own solicitor, so the advice is independent and the agreement is more likely to be respected.
Generally not. Your interests may conflict, and a solicitor cannot properly advise both sides.
Not automatically. But it can weaken the agreement, because the court has less evidence that each person understood and freely agreed to the terms.
As early as you can. Starting several months before the wedding leaves time for disclosure, negotiation and calm decision-making.
International couples can still make a prenup, but it is important to take advice on which country's courts may apply and whether the agreement will be recognised.
If you want to understand your options or have an existing agreement reviewed, our family law solicitors at Regent Law can help. Contact us to arrange a free, no-obligation assessment.