What Happens If One Partner Doesn’t Want a Prenup?

It is a situation we see often at Regent Law: one partner would like the reassurance of a prenuptial agreement before marriage, while the other feels uneasy, offended, or simply does not see the need for one.

This mismatch can create real tension in the run-up to a wedding, but it does not have to. Understanding the legal position, and the options available, often takes the emotion out of the conversation and helps couples find a way forward together.

Why One Partner Might Resist a Prenup

There are usually understandable reasons behind reluctance. Some partners worry that discussing a prenup signals a lack of commitment or trust, or feel that it undermines the romance of getting married.

Others simply have less to protect financially and cannot see why an agreement is necessary. Sometimes the resistance is about timing, feeling that the topic has come up too late, or too suddenly, rather than a genuine objection to the concept itself.

It helps to remember that a prenuptial agreement is not a prediction that a marriage will fail. As family lawyers often put it, a good prenup is best thought of as an agreement you hope you will never need to rely on, much like an insurance policy kept in a drawer. Framing the conversation this way, as a sensible planning exercise rather than a statement of doubt, often reduces resistance considerably.

The Legal Position If No Agreement Is in Place

If a couple marries without a prenuptial agreement, and one partner did not want one, nothing prevents the marriage from proceeding. Legally, there is no requirement to have a prenup before marrying in England and Wales. However, it is worth understanding what this means if the marriage were ever to end in divorce.

Without a prenuptial agreement, the division of finances is left to the court's discretion under the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973. The court considers a wide range of factors, including the length of the marriage, each party's income and earning capacity, their needs and those of any children, and the standard of living during the marriage.

There is no automatic 50/50 split, but equally there is no guarantee that assets brought into the marriage, such as a property owned before the wedding, an inheritance, or a business, will be treated as entirely separate. This is precisely the uncertainty a prenup is designed to reduce.

Compromise Options When One Partner Is Reluctant

When one partner is unwilling to sign a full prenuptial agreement, couples often find a workable middle ground rather than abandoning the idea entirely.

  • A narrower agreement that only ring-fences specific assets, such as a family business, inherited property, or savings built up before the relationship began, rather than covering every aspect of the couple's finances
  • Agreeing to marry without a prenup, but committing to a postnuptial agreement once both partners feel less time pressure and can approach the conversation calmly
  • Setting a clear framework for how certain assets, such as future inheritance, will be treated, without needing a full financial disclosure exercise on both sides
  • Using a declaration of trust for a specific property, which is a simpler legal tool than a full nuptial agreement

Talking About It Without Damaging Trust

The way the conversation is raised matters just as much as the content of any agreement. We often advise clients to start the discussion early, well before wedding planning is in full swing, and to frame it around practical protection for both partners rather than suspicion of one.

Explaining the reasoning clearly, whether that is a family business, children from a previous relationship, or an expected inheritance, tends to land better than presenting a document with no context.

It is also worth acknowledging your partner's feelings directly. Reassuring them that raising the topic is not a judgment on the relationship, and that they will have their own independent legal advice throughout, can go a long way towards easing resistance.

When to Seek Independent Advice

If discussions have stalled, or one partner feels pressured either to sign or to abandon the idea altogether, it is a good moment for each of you to speak to your own solicitor separately.

Independent advice ensures that whatever you decide, whether that is a full prenup, a narrower agreement, a postnuptial agreement after the wedding, or no agreement at all, is a genuinely informed choice made without pressure on either side.

At Regent Law, we regularly help couples navigate exactly this kind of disagreement. We can advise you individually, explain the practical implications of each option in plain terms, and help find a solution that both partners can feel comfortable with, without the process becoming adversarial.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes. There is no legal requirement to have a prenuptial agreement before marrying in England and Wales. The marriage can go ahead regardless of whether an agreement is in place.

The court will decide how to divide finances based on general fairness principles under the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, considering factors such as length of marriage, income, needs, and children. There is no automatic equal split, but assets are not automatically protected either.

It can be. A postnuptial agreement covers the same ground as a prenup but is signed after the marriage, once there is less time pressure. It is assessed by the courts using the same fairness principles as a prenuptial agreement.

Not necessarily. Many couples find that an open, well-timed conversation about finances actually strengthens trust, particularly when both partners have their own independent legal advice and understand the reasoning behind the request.

Yes. Independent legal advice for both partners is essential, whether you are proposing an agreement or considering whether to sign one. It ensures that whatever is agreed, or not agreed, is a properly informed decision.

If you and your partner disagree about whether to have a prenuptial agreement, our family law solicitors at Regent Law can help you both understand your options clearly and reach a resolution that respects everyone's position. Get in touch to arrange a confidential conversation.